Your plant-based happy place. Welcome to the veginner community! ♡

← Back to the recipe box

Dessert · Snacks

Vegan Peanut Butter Cups

Trick or treat, homemade edition. 🎃 Peanut butter cups were one of my favorite childhood candies, so of course I wanted a vegan version. Chocolate outside, creamy peanut butter inside, and that little moment of satisfaction when you pop one out of its mold. If there are leftovers... well, we can discuss that later.

↓ Jump to recipe📌 Pin it
Vegan Peanut Butter Cups
THE RECIPE

Vegan Peanut Butter Cups

Check off ingredients as you go. Apron optional. Appetite encouraged.

📌 Pin it
⏱ Prep 10 min♨ Cook 0 minTotal 40 minYield: 30

What you'll need

30servings

Let's get cooking!

Your childhood candy crush, with chocolate-layer tricks and useful swap notes.

Use the mold you have

Silicone candy molds make tidy mini cups, while cupcake liners in a muffin tin give you the familiar larger shape. Keep them clean and dry before adding chocolate. Mini and full-size cups use the same batch differently, so the number of pieces depends on your mold.

Melt gently, stir patiently

Warm the chocolate in short microwave intervals, stirring between each, or use a heatproof bowl over gently simmering water without letting the bowl touch the water. Keep water out of the chocolate. Stop heating once stirring will melt the last small pieces.

Keep the filling tucked inside

Make a thin chocolate base, then flatten the filling into discs small enough to leave space around the edges. Cover with the remaining chocolate so the sides can join into a shell. Tap the mold gently to level the tops and release visible air bubbles.

Not every swap sets the same

Maple syrup or agave are original filling options. The source lists different flour choices in its ingredient and instruction text, and coconut, oat, and almond flour do not absorb moisture identically. Add a thickener gradually if adapting, and do not assume a one-for-one result. Likewise, liquid oils can leave a softer shell than coconut oil; the original oil alternatives are experiments, not identical replacements.

Let them set before the taste test

Give the cups the full chilling time and unmold only when firm. Keep extras covered in the fridge or freezer with parchment between layers. Seed butter is a possible flavor variation, but an allergy-safe version requires checking the chocolate, thickener, and all equipment too. For another chocolate project, try rice crispy chocolate bars.

A closer look

Agave nectar and vanilla extractHomemade Reese's peanut butter cups homemade vegan peanut butter cups
Veginner Cooking photo
Veginner Cooking photo

A LITTLE HELP FROM MY KITCHEN

What can I help you whip up?